Sony cameras have lengthy been criticized for his or her shade science. The notion is that Sony cameras produce unflattering colours, particularly for pores and skin tones. This declare appears to be leaning in direction of uncooked information processed in Lightroom. Seize One is usually really helpful, so, let’s discover out which of the 2 software program is the higher choice for Sony uncooked information.
In a earlier article, we in contrast Canon uncooked information processed in Lightroom and Seize One. For this second article within the collection, we will likely be focussing on uncooked information from Sony cameras. The important thing picture on this comparability was shot with the Sony a7R III with the Sigma 65mm f/2.0 lens.
This primary picture above is a JPEG file taken straight out of the digital camera with none processing from any software program. The straight out of digital camera picture above will function a degree of reference solely and doesn’t essentially function a benchmark on this comparability. We will now begin this comparability by taking a look at how photos look from every software program.
For Lightroom I used the Sony Digital camera Normal profile and the in Seize One, I used the Professional Normal profile.
The primary variations between the 2 are that Seize One leans extra into the magenta tones and has extra distinction. The Lightroom picture is just a little hotter with a slight bias in direction of the inexperienced tones together with rather less distinction. Neither picture matches the JPEG that got here straight out of the digital camera, though that is not a measure of efficiency.
Having mentioned that, in case you are searching for a extra constant workflow there’s fairly a simple method to do that in Lightroom. If you use the usual Adobe default profile, it matches the out-of-camera JPEG comparatively nicely.
The distinction is that the out-of-camera picture from Sony has extra distinction and saturation. The truth that the Lightroom default picture has much less distinction and saturation might show helpful for those who’re planning on modifying and shade grading your picture. This consistency might find yourself providing a variety of worth to your workflow. Basically, what you see on the again of your display screen will likely be near what you see in your laptop display screen if you sit all the way down to edit.
Then again, in Seize One the colours and the general look will not match the producer’s profile the way in which that Lightroom does. Seize One basically makes use of its personal principle for shade and that is in no way a nasty factor as a result of loads of photographers want the way in which Seize One processes uncooked information. The outcomes from Seize One is probably not as constant, nevertheless, for a lot of creatives, that is truly a function.
The one draw back to Seize One is that it tends to be extremely aggressive when making use of sharpening. On the floor this makes photos from the software program look crisp and presents an phantasm of extra element. In apply, the sharpening in Seize One can lead to just a few undesirable points.
As you’ll be able to see within the comparability above, the Seize One picture seems to be sharper. It seems to have extra element resulting from the way it’s processing the information. Nonetheless, photos can find yourself wanting harsh. That is particularly the case in relation to pores and skin texture and tones.
As you begin to edit the picture with just a little extra which means in purposes similar to Photoshop, the additional sharpening utilized in Seize One might find yourself being a hindrance. This is among the causes I want to fully change off the sharpening in Seize One. Any sharpening that I do apply tends to be utilized in Photoshop by extra devoted software program similar to Sharpen AI from Topaz Labs
With Lightroom, nevertheless, the sharpening is comparatively benign. I’ve by no means had a state of affairs the place the default sharpening settings have are available the way in which of my workflow. The sharpening in Lightroom has a constructive impact on the picture as a result of it enhances the element with out damaging the integrity of the file. I can fairly comfortably go away the sharpening settings on in Lightroom, and apply additional sharpening in Photoshop with out it turning into extreme of particulars wanting harsh.
Having mentioned that, this is not by any means a significant downside in Seize One. It takes little or no effort to modify off the sharpening options in Seize One, due to this fact, it is not likely a problem The one purpose I am discussing that is merely to focus on the variations between the 2 software program.
Lastly, now we have a comparability under that demonstrates photos from each software program as soon as they’ve been shade graded.
Each photos within the above comparability had been processed with the default settings of their respective software program. Then they had been taken into Photoshop the place every picture obtained the very same therapy. A number of layers of publicity, shade, and texture had been utilized to the information and exported.
Curiously, even if every had the identical therapy, the outcomes are noticeably totally different. The Seize One picture has a brighter background and leans just a little extra into the pink and magenta tones. Lightroom however has a barely light look to it. It additionally leans extra in direction of earthy and inexperienced tones. The background additionally seems darker and fewer saturated compared.
What’s most curious is the truth that neither outcome seems to be improper. There is not any doubt that the pictures look totally different, nevertheless, neither of the 2 outcomes seem displeasing. Basically, it comes down to private choice and relies on what you suppose seems to be higher.
Although I take advantage of Seize One for extra significant tasks, the concept Lightroom is unhealthy or that it would not produce handsome outcomes is not true. There are clear variations between the 2 software program, nevertheless, it is completely primarily based on choice. Seize One operates utilizing its personal shade principle, which I take pleasure in and like to make use of for my work. Lightroom, however, leans extra in direction of what the digital camera producers supposed. And the outcomes look nice from every.
It is necessary to do not forget that how the pictures are introduced in every software program, will undoubtedly change the way in which you understand the tip outcome. Though I utilized the identical remedies to the pictures within the closing comparability, that is clearly not how somebody would work in real-world circumstances. Nonetheless, highlighting the variations between the 2 software program might show you how to determine which one works finest for you. Fortuitously, what you might be sure of is the truth that both of the 2 choices will produce great-looking outcomes.
Which do you favor, Lightroom or Seize One?